This blog should begin with an admission: Ntozake Shange’s For Colored Girls is sacred
text to me. I know passages from it by heart. I’ve been known to recite excerpts from
it to myself when dealing with situations where her words were balm.
To say I had trepidation about experiencing it in the hands of Tyler Perry would be the
grossest of understatements. But I walked up to theater on the day that it opened,
reminding myself that what I was going to see was not For Colored Girls Who Have
Considered Suicide When The Rainbow Was Enuf… I was going to see a motion picture
that was inspired by it. A movie whose very artistically done promotional materials
highlighted an array of additional characters not included in the original script. I
expected that a new narrative would be imposed, and that the set would be revised
to make it conducive to a film format. This was a new something, not to be received
or processed as one might with a production of the play.
I came away from it feeling conflicted. Here’s what I liked: I was glad to
see such able actors have the opportunity to work with Ntozake’s words in a high
profile capacity. I’m excited about the idea that a new audience will be introduced to
her work and may be inspired to seek out the original text along with her other
books. I like that this movie is a history maker in terms of having a cohort of black
women headliners.
However, the movie felt… heavy to me. Core poems were truncated and I was uncomfortable with the addition of back story lines that showcased overwhelmingly negative depictions of Black men. I am cautious about writing that because I know that so many feminist books and films have been assailed for that reason, often wrongly. But, this was something new. And the portrayals of men that were added to Perry’s adaptation of Shange’s seminal work lacked resonance. I also didn’t like what that redirected focus on Black male pathology did to the stories of the women. A direct consequence of vilifying the brothers is that the sisters were stained with the taint of victimhood. Which is not how the play ever read or presented to me. In fact, I would argue that is the polar opposite of the play’s intent.
For Colored Girls is a classic that endured through the decades because Shange, as a master of her craft, managed to thread light through words that described some of the deepest horrors that afflict us. Traumatic stories of rape, infidelity, abortion, and domestic violence that morphs into murder were told through a lens that emphasized our humanity, our endurance, our survival and triumph. The focus was on Black women’s ability to retain our joy, find God in ourselves and love her. Fiercely.
In the closing montage that depicts the eight women leaning on each other, I wanted to feel the transcendent feeling I got from watching this extraordinary performance of Four Women:
Instead I was going down the line thinking “damn, this one got cheated on, those two both got STDs, that one’s man was wilding, she was sexually assaulted, etc, etc.” The feeling of celebration and victory, that’s the magic that was missing from this movie.
But, since it did gross over $20 million in its opening weekend, my hope is that this film’s economic success will serve as a gateway for sister filmmakers like Julie Dash, Kasi Lemmons or Nzingha Stewart (who originally optioned FCG and received executive producer credit for this) to seize the stage and take their turn at telling our stories with the financial backing and expanded audience that they deserve. I also hope that this will mark a turning point in Perry’s oeuvre, perhaps we’ll see more projects from him that work to show a more complex and nuanced portrayal of our communities. And it would be wonderful if more authors of Shange’s caliber and more actors like the amazing cast that was assembled for FCG get the increased opportunities they so richly merit.

















